Vintage 2012 FALSTAFF Ultimate Wine Guide 24/25: 96 points Medium greenish yellow, silver reflection, very fine, persistent mousse. Delicate bakery notes, fine yellow tropical fruit, hints of mango, white nougat, attractive bouquet. Taut, tightly meshed, white apple fruit, racy structure, lime on the finish, very youthful, mineral, good length, certain ageing potential. (Deg.11/22)
Vintage 2010 ROBERT PARKER - The Wine Advocate 12/21: 94 points Disgorged in September 2020, the 2010 Vintage Grosse Reserve Extra Brut exhibits a lemon-yellow color along with an intense and complex but fresh bouquet with delicate brut notes intermixed with lemony and yeasty aromas. Full-bodied, round and complex on the palate, this is a dry and vinous sparkling wine with stimulating lemon aromas on the pure, clear and fresh finish. This is an impressive sparkling wine to be served during a meal (fish, poultry, veal, cheese).
Vintage 2008 Wine Enthusiast 10/19: 93 points Creamy, lemony chalkiness on the nose promises a serious wine, with some age. The slender palate comes in with tiny bubbles of creamy foam, dancing against a yeasty, chalky, stony backdrop. They release notions of lemon and honey, contradictory notions that create drama, richness and freshness. The finish is creamy, intense with chalkiness, long and dry. -Anne Krebiehl MW
WEIN PUR TROPHY - Genuss 8/2018: 97 points / outstanding Certificate